Local Review Body - 26 April 2011

 

Local Review Body - 26 April 2011

Last updated | 21/04/2011

A Meeting of the Local Review Body will be held in the Council Chambers, Fourth Floor, Council Building, 2 High street, Perth on Tuesday 26 April 2011 at 10.00am.

If you have any queries please contact Yvonne Oliver on (01738) 475125 or Christina Flynn on (01738) 475450.

Those attending the meeting are requested to ensure that all mobile phones and other communication devices are switched off.

Members

Councillor M Lyle, Councillor W Lumsden, Councillor I Campbell 

Agenda

1. Declarations of Interest

2. Minute of Meeting of Local Review Body of 29 March 2011

3. Applications for Review
   

   (i) TCP/11/16(87)
   Planning Application 10/01667/FLL – Extension to dwellinghouse South Bank Cowgate Errol Perth PH2 7QS – Review Papers Attached
   

   (a)  Papers Submitted by the Applicant [PDF: 3.72Mb] (Pages 9-20)

   (b)  Planning Decision Notice, Report of Handling and Reference Documents [PDF: 273Kb] (Pages 21-30)

   (c)  Representations [PDF: 723Kb] (Pages 31-48)
   

   • Representation from Scottish Water, dated 15 October 2010
   • Representation from Conservation Officer, dated 22 October 2010
   • Objection from The Architectural Heritage Society of Scotland, dated 25 October 2010
   • Objection from Mr A Nixon and Dr J Gouick, dated 25 October 2010
   • Representation from Mr A Nixon and Dr J Gouick, dated 7 March 2011
   • Response to representation from Applicant, dated 18 March 2011

   (ii) TCP/11/16(88)
   Planning Application 10/01815/FLL – alterations to vehicular access – land 50 metres Northwest of Easter Orchilmore Farmhouse, Killiecrankie – Review Papers Attached
   

   (a)  Papers Submitted by the Applicant [PDF: 2.77Mb] (Pages 49-86)

   (b)  Planning Decision Notice, Report of Handling and Reference Documents [PDF: 253Kb] (Pages 87-94)

   (c)  Representations [PDF: 1.32Mb] (Pages 95-110)
   

   • Objection from Neil Whittet Solicitors, on behalf of Miss B Stagg and Mr S Ramsay, dated 2 November 2010
   • Representation from Transport Planning, dated 7 November 2010
   • Objection from Miss B Stagg and Mr S Ramsay, dated 11 November 2010
   • Representation from Neil Whittet Solicitors, on behalf of Mr S Ramsay and Miss B Stagg, dated 28 February 2011
   • Representation from Miss B Stagg and Mr S Ramsay, dated 7 March 2011
   • Response to Representations from Agent, dated 22 March 2011

   (iii) TCP/11/16(91)
   Planning Application 10/01345/FLL – Change of use of outbuilding and part of garden ground in connection with second-hand car sales at Pitversie Bungalow, Perth Road, Abernethy, PH2 9LU – Review Papers Attached
   

   (a)  Papers Submitted by the Applicant [PDF: 3.11Mb] (Pages 111-124b)

   (b)  Planning Decision Notice, Report of Handling and Reference Documents [PDF: 1.42Mb] (Pages 125-130)

   (c)  Representations [PDF: 2.06Mb] (Pages 131-162)
   

   • Representation from Scottish Water, dated 9 August 2010
   • Objection from Mrs E Marr, dated 11 August 2010
   • Objection from Mr and Mrs Sangster, dated 12 August 2010
   • Objection from Michael Wilson, dated 13 August 2010
   • Withdrawal of objection from Mr A H Smith, dated 14 August 2010
   • Objection from Wyn Dobbie, dated 14 August 2010
   • Objection from Mrs S Corstorphine, dated 16 August 2010
   • Objection from Brian Garrick, dated 18 August 2010
   • Objection from Mr D Gillespie, dated 18 August 2010
   • Objection from Michael Jamieson, dated 20 August 2010
   • Representation from Environmental Health Officer, dated 5 October 2010
   • Representation from Mr and Mrs Sangster, dated 26 March 2011
   • Representations from Mrs E Marr, dated 28 and 29 March 2011
   • Response to Representations from Agent, dated 5 April 2011

   (iv) TCP/11/16(92)
   Planning Application 10/01877/FLL – Erection of a Finnforest ‘Helpo’ cabin at The Cottage, Cultybraggan, Comrie, PH6 2HX – Review Papers Attached
   

   (a)  Papers Submitted by the Applicant [PDF: 9.06Mb] (Pages 163-184)

   (b)  Planning Decision Notice, Report of Handling and Reference Documents [PDF: 1.6Mb] (Pages 185-196)

   (v) TCP/11/16(93)
   Planning Application 10/02101/FLL – Review of Condition 5 on planning permission 10/02101/FLL for extension to house and new garage at Sunnyside, South Crieff Road, Comrie, PH6 2HF – Review Papers Attached
   

   (a)  Papers Submitted by the Applicant [PDF: 1.09Mb] (Pages 197-202)

   (b)  Planning Decision Notice, Report of Handling and Reference Documents [PDF: 1.41Mb] (Pages 203-226)

   (c)  Representations [PDF: 536Kb] (Pages 227-232)
   

   • Representation from Community Greenspace Manager, dated 2 February 2011
   • Representation from Conservation Technician, dated 1 March 2011

   (vi) TCP/11/16(95)
   Planning Application 10/01977/FLL – Erection of 2 dwellinghouses on land to west of Old Schoolhouse, Rannoch Station, Pitlochry, PH17 2QA – Review Papers Attached
   

   (a)  Papers Submitted by the Applicant [PDF: 2.58Mb] (Pages 233-278)

   (b)  Planning Decision Notice, Report of Handling and Reference Documents [PDF: 394Kb] (Pages 279-290)

   (c)  Representations [PDF: 252Kb] (Pages 291-294)
   

   • Representation from Transport Planning, dated 13 January 2011

   (vii) TCP/11/16(96)
   Planning Application 10/01768/IPL – Erection of dwellinghouse (in principle) at land 100 metres south east of Briglands Lodge, Crook of Devon, KY13 0PS – Review Papers Attached
   

   (a)  Papers Submitted by the Applicant [PDF: 6.91Mb] (Pages 295-336)

   (b)  Planning Decision Notice, Report of Handling and Reference Documents [PDF: 250Kb] (Pages 337-340)

   (c)  Representations [PDF: 253Kb] (Pages 341-346)
   

   • Representation from Conservation Technician, dated 4 November 2011
   • Representation from Transport Planning, 8 December 2010

4. Deferred Applications for Review
   

   Site Visit
   

   NOTE The following application was deferred for the purposes of an accompanied site visit taking place prior to consideration.

   (i) TCP/11/16(90)
   Planning Application 10/01827/FLL – Alterations and extension to existing dwellinghouse at Distillery House, Milton of Edradour, PH16 5JP – Review Papers Attached
   

   (a)  Papers Submitted by the Applicant [PDF: 2.13Mb] (Pages 347-362)

   (b)  Planning Decision Notice, Report of Handling and Reference Documents [PDF: 2.5Mb] (Pages 363-378)

   (c)  Representations [PDF: 237Kb] (Pages 379-382)
   

   • Memo of objection from Conservation Officer, dated 23 November 2010

   Site Visit and Written Submissions
   

   NOTE The following application was deferred for the purposes of an unaccompanied site visit taking place and further written submissions prior to consideration.

   (ii) TCP/11/16(66)
   Planning Application 10/01102/IPL – Creation of new residential plot within gardens of existing house at land 15 metres north east of Silverstone, Perth Road, Crieff, PH7 3EQ – Review Papers Attached
   

   (a)  Papers Submitted by the Applicant [PDF: 5.23Mb] (Pages 383-424)

   (b)  Planning Decision Notice, Report of Handling and Reference Documents [PDF: 542Kb] (Pages 425-438)

   (c)  Written Submission by the Agent [PDF: 1.99Mb] (Pages 439-448)

   (d)  Written Submission by The Environment Service [PDF: 3.58Mb] (Pages 449-484)

   Site Visits and Hearing Sessions
   

   NOTE The following items were deferred for unaccompanied site visits to take place prior to consideration at Hearing Sessions.

   (iii)  Procedure to be used for Hearing [PDF: 233Kb] (Pages 485-486)

   (iv) TCP/11/16(56)
   Planning Application 08/00236/FLL – Erection of a dwellinghouse at Appin Cottage, Strowan Road, Comrie – Review Papers Attached
   

   (a)  Papers Submitted by the Applicant [PDF: 8.1Mb] (Pages 487-510)

   (b)  Planning Decision Notice, Report of Handling and Reference Documents [PDF: 224Kb] (Pages 511-512)

   (c)  Representations [PDF: 0.81Mb] (Pages 513-546)
   

   • Letter of objection from Mr K Ritchie (now deceased), dated 13 February 2008
   • Letter of objection from Owner/Occupier of 18 Glebe Road, Comrie, dated 13 February 2008
   • Letter of objection from Mr J Hepburn, dated 15 February 2008
   • Letter of objection from Mr I Walker, dated 15 February 2008
   • Letter of objection from Ms J Welsh, dated 15 February 2008
   • Memo from Transport Planning, dated 6 March 2008
   • Letter from Scottish Water, dated 17 March 2008
   • Letter of objection from SEPA, dated 9 April 2008
   • Letter of objection from SEPA, dated 29 April 2009
   • Letter of objection from SEPA, dated 13 May 2010
   • Letter of representation from Mr and Mrs Phillips, dated 15 September 2010
   • Email from agent in response to representation from Mr and Mrs Phillips, dated 24 September 2010

   (d)  Hearing Statement submitted by the Agent [PDF: 2.1Mb] (Pages 547-576)

   (e)  Hearing Statement submitted by the Scottish Environment Protection Agency [PDF: 267Kb] (Pages 577-582)

   (f)  Hearing Statement submitted by The Environment Service [PDF: 258Kb] (Pages 583-586)

   (v) TCP/11/16(59)
   Planning Application 10/00510/IPL – Residential development (in principle) at land adjacent to Churchmouse Cottage, Carnbo – Review Papers Attached
   

   (a)  Papers Submitted by the Applicant [PDF: 3.83Mb] (Pages 587-616)

   (b)  Planning Decision Notice, Report of Handling and Reference Documents [PDF: 798Kb] (Pages 617-630)

   (c)  Representations [PDF: 701Kb] (Pages 631-652)
   

   • Letter from Scottish Water, dated 6 April 2010
   • Letter from Scottish Water, dated 12 April 2010
   • Letter of objection from Fossoway and District Community Council, dated 13 April 2010
   • Letter of objection from Mrs E Lavery, dated 13 April 2010
   • Letter of support from M Drummond, dated 13 April 2010
   • Letter from SEPA, dated 15 April 2010
   • Letter of objection from Mr G Watt, dated 15 April 2010
   • Email of support from Mr H McLaren, dated 15 April 2010
   • Email of support from Mr I Kenny, dated 16 April 2010
   • Memo from Transport Planning, dated 17 May 2010

   (d)  Indicative Site Layout submitted by the Agent [PDF: 0.87Mb] (Pages 653-658)

   (e)  Further Representations [PDF: 1.52Mb] (Pages 659-674)
   

   • Representation from Henry McLaren, dated 12 February 2011
   • Representation from Marion Drummond, dated 13 February 2011
   • Representation from Ian Kenny, dated 15 February 2011
   • Representation from George Watt, dated 15 February 2011
   • Representation from Dr Alastair Lavery, dated 15 February 2011
   • Response to Representations from Agent, dated 7 March 2011

   (f)  Hearing Statement submitted by the Agent [PDF: 5.97Mb] (Pages 675-682)

   (vi) TCP/11/16(80)
   Planning Application 10/01224/FLL – Installation of 2 225kw ACSA wind turbines at Dunduff House, Braco Castle Farm, Braco, FK15 9LA – Review Papers Attached
   

   (a)  Papers Submitted by the Applicant [PDF: 21.53Mb] (Pages 683-770)

   (b)  Planning Decision Notice, Report of Handling and Reference Documents [PDF: 2.28Mb] (Pages 771-798)

   (c)  Representations [PDF: 300Kb] (Pages 799-804)
   

   • Email of representation from Mr C Castle, Scottish Natural Heritage, dated 20 August 2010
   • Memo of representation from Environmental Health Manager, dated 26 August 2010

   (d)  Hearing Statement submitted by the Agent [PDF: 19.35Mb] (Pages 805-858)

   (e)  Hearing Statement submitted by The Environment Service [PDF: 346Kb] (Pages 859-862)