Local Review Body - 29 March 2011

 

Local Review Body - 29 March 2011

Last updated | 25/03/2011

A Meeting of the Local Review Body will be held in the Council Chambers, Fourth Floor, Council Building, 2 High Street, Perth on Tuesday 29 March 2011 at 10.00am.

If you have any queries please contact Yvonne Oliver on (01738) 475125 or Christina Flynn on (01738) 475450.

Those attending the meeting are requested to ensure that all mobile phones and other communication devices are switched off.

Members

Councillors M Lyle (Vice Convener), I Campbell and W Lumsden

Agenda

1. Declarations of Interest

2. Minute of Meeting of Local Review Body of 1 March 2011

3. Applications for Review
   

   (i) TCP/11/16(85)
   Planning Application 10/01318/FLL – Change of use of part of an existing residential curtilage to store 6 campervans in connection with campervan hire business at Birch House, Church Lane, Bankfoot, PH1 4BD – Review Papers Attached
   

   (a)  Papers Submitted by the Applicant [PDF: 7.75Mb] (Pages 5-36)

   (b)  Planning Decision Notice, Report of Handling and Reference Documents [PDF: 749Kb] (Pages 37-44)

   (c)  Representations [PDF: 238Kb] (Pages 45-46)

   • Email of objection from Mr J Gordon, dated 11 September 2010

   (ii) TCP/11/16(86)
   Planning Application 10/01509/FLL – Extension to form new entrance and kitchen at The Cottage, Forteviot, PH2 9BT – Review Papers Attached
   

   (a)  Papers Submitted by the Applicant [PDF: 1.53Mb] (Pages 47-54)

   (b)  Planning Decision Notice, Report of Handling and Reference Documents [PDF: 1.41Mb] (Pages 55-72)
   

   (iii) TCP/11/16(89)
   Planning Application 10/01627/FLL – Replacement of 5 windows at 142D South Street, Perth, PH2 8PA – Review Papers Attached
   

   (a)  Papers Submitted by the Applicant [PDF: 12.25Mb] (Pages 73-158)

   (b)  Planning Decision Notice, Report of Handling and Reference Documents [PDF: 1.04Mb] (Pages 159-170)

   (c)  Representations [PDF: 236Kb] (Pages 171-172)
   

   • Letter of objection from The Architectural Heritage Society of Scotland, dated 13 October 2010
   • Email from Conservation Technician, dated 18 October 2010

   (iv) TCP/11/16(90)
   Planning Application 10/01827/FLL – Alterations and extension to existing dwellinghouse at Distillery House, Milton of Edradour, PH16 5JP – Review Papers Attached
   

   (a)  Papers Submitted by the Applicant [PDF: 1.92Mb] (Pages 173-188)

   (b)  Planning Decision Notice, Report of Handling and Reference Documents [PDF: 3.31Mb] (Pages 189-204)

   (c)  Representations [PDF: 251Kb] (Pages 205-208)
   

   • Memo of objection from Conservation Officer, dated 23 November 2010

4. Request for Agreement of Conditions
   

   NOTE The following application was approved by the Local Review Body on 5 January 2010, subject to conditions, etc to be drawn up by the Planning Adviser, in consultation with the Head of Planning, such conditions to be submitted to a future meeting of the Local Review Body for agreement.

   (i) TCP/11/16(2)
   Planning Application 09/00733/FLL – Erection of a dwellinghouse at Wester Camghouran, South Loch Rannoch, PH17 2QG – Review Papers Attached
   

   (a)  Extract from Minute of Meeting of 5 January 2010 [PDF: 248Kb] (Pages 209-212)

   (b)  Decision Notice for Approval [PDF: 264Kb] (Pages 213-218)

5. Deferred Applications for Review
   

   Further Guidance Required
   

   NOTE The following item was deferred for clarification of the drawing to be considered with the review application.

   (i) TCP/11/16(78)
   Planning Application 10/00950/FLL – Demolish existing structurally unsound extension and erect replacement, thereby supporting existing building and disguise outward signs of subsidence – Review Papers Attached
   

   (a)  Papers Submitted by the Applicant [PDF: 7.83Mb] (Pages 219-264)

   (b)  Planning Decision Notice, Report of Handling and Reference Documents [PDF: 1.41Mb] (Pages 265-274)

   (c)  Representations [PDF: 1.48Mb] (Pages 275-302)
   

   • Email of objection from Mr N Barclay, dated 22 June 2010
   • Email of objection from Mr and Mrs Gregory, dated 29 June 2010
   • Email of objection from Mrs Mack, dated 4 July 2010
   • Letter of objection from Mr R Stewart, dated 4 July 2010
   • Emails of objection from Mr and Mrs Vickers, dated 6 and 7 July 2010
   • Letter of representation from Mr N Barclay, dated 21 December 2010
   • Letter of representation from Mr R Stewart, dated 29 December 2010
   • Letter of representation from Mr and Mrs Vickers, dated 30 December 2010
   • Letter of response to representations from Applicant, dated 24 January 2011
   
   NOTE The following item was deferred for the provision of further information from the applicant, which information has not been submitted.

   (ii) TCP/11/16(80)
   Planning Application 10/01224/FLL – Installation of 2 225kw ACSA wind turbines at Dunduff House, Braco Castle Farm, Braco, FK15 9LA – Review Papers Attached
   

   (a)  Papers Submitted by the Applicant [PDF: 21.35Mb] (Pages 303-390)

   (b)  Planning Decision Notice, Report of Handling and Reference Documents [PDF: 2.56Mb] (Pages 391-418)

   (c)  Representations [PDF: 302Kb] (Pages 419-424)

   • Email of representation from Mr C Castle, Scottish Natural Heritage, dated 20 August 2010
   • Memo of representation from Environmental Health Manager, dated 26 August 2010
   
   NOTE The following item was deferred for the purpose of obtaining written submissions.

   (iii) TCP/11/16(65)
   Planning Application 10/01060/FLL – Erection of chalet at The Bungalow, East Haugh, Pitlochry, PH16 5TB – Review Papers Attached
   

   (a)  Papers Submitted by the Applicant [PDF: 7.76Mb] (Pages 425-456)

   (b)  Planning Decision Notice, Report of Handling and Reference Documents [PDF: 241Kb] (Pages 457-462)

   (c)  Written Submission [PDF: 516Kb] (Pages 463-466)
   

   Site Visit
   

   NOTE The following application was deferred for the purposes of a site visit taking place prior to consideration.

   (iv) TCP/11/16(81)
   Planning Application 10/00968/FLL – Demolition of cottage and erection of 8 care cottages, 8 care apartments, 2 garages and formation of road and associated parking at Stonefield, Golf Course Road, Blairgowrie, PH10 6LJ – Review Papers Attached
   

   (a)  Papers Submitted by the Applicant [PDF: 2.85Mb] (Pages 467-480)

   (b)  Planning Decision Notice, Report of Handling and Reference Documents [PDF: 4.26Mb] (Pages 481-502)

   (c)  Representations [PDF: 12.31Mb] (Pages 503-618)
   

   • Letters of objection from Dr Ian Brown, dated 10 June and 2 July 2010
   • Letter of objection from Stewart Robertson, dated 4 July 2010
   • Letter of representation from Scottish Water, dated 5 July 2010
   • Letter of objection from Mr and Mrs Turner, dated 8 July 2010
   • Letter of representation from Transport Planning, dated 8 July 2010
   • Email of objection from Mr and Mrs Clark, dated 8 July 2010
   • Letter of objection from Mr and Mrs Boyle, dated 8 July 2010
   • Letter of objection from Adrian Dirkzwager, dated 8 July 2010
   • Email of objection from Mr and Mrs Ogilvy, dated 8 July 2010
   • Letter of objection from Mrs Cooper, dated 9 July 2010
   • Email of objection from Adrian Dirkzwager, dated 9 July 2010
   • Letter of objection from Mrs Scott, dated 10 July 2010
   • Letter of objection from ‘Isdell’, dated 13 July 2010
   • Email of objection from Mr and Mrs Meikle, dated 13 July 2010
   • Letter of objection from Ms Sidsel Thome, dated 13 July 2010
   • Letter of objection from Mr K Stewart, dated 14 July 2010
   • Letter of objection from Kathryn MacNab, dated 14 July 2010
   • Letter of objection from Mr and Mrs Barrow, dated 14 July 2010
   • Letter of objection from Mr and Mrs Patterson, dated 15 July 2010
   • Email of objection from Mr S Robertson, dated 15 July 2010
   • Letter of objection from ‘Garrymore’, received 19 July 2010
   • Letter of objection from Alexander Murdoch, dated 19 July 2010
   • Email of objection from Jim Bradley, dated 19 July 2010
   • Letter of objection from Mr and Mrs Anderson, received 19 July 2010
   • Memo of representation from Head of Environment and Regulatory Services, dated 21 July 2010
   • Letter of objection from Euan Walker, received 22 July 2010
   • Representation from Mr and Mrs Barrow, dated 7 January 2011
   • Representation from Adrian Dirkzwager, dated 9 January 2011
   • Representation from Mr and Mrs Walker, dated 9 January 2011
   • Representation from Mr and Mrs Anderson, dated 9 January 2011
   • Representation from Dr I Brown, dated 10 January 2011
   • Representation from Kenneth Stewart, dated 11 January 2011
   • Representation from Stewart Robertson, dated 11 January 2011
   • Representation from Mr and Mrs Clark, dated 11 January 2011
   • Representation from Mr and Mrs Caldwell, dated 14 January 2011
   • Representation from Mr and Mrs Ogilvy, dated 18 January 2011
   • Representation from Mr and Mrs Cooper, dated 18 January 2011
   • Representation from Sandy Murdoch, dated 19 January 2011
   • Representation from Jean Calder
   • Representation from Kathryn MacNab
   • Response to representations from Agent, dated 3 February 2011