Local Review Body - 31 August 2010

 

Local Review Body - 31 August 2010

Last updated | 26/08/2010

A Meeting of the Local Review Body will be held in the Council Chambers, Fourth Floor, 2 High Street, Perth on Tuesday 31 August 2010 at 10.00am.

If you have any queries please contact Yvonne Oliver on (01738) 475125 or Andrew Wilson on (01738) 475172.

Those attending the meeting are requested to ensure that all mobile phones and other communication devices are switched off.

Members

Councillors B Band (Convener), M Lyle (Vice Convener) and K Lyall

Agenda

1. Declarations of Interest

2. Minute of Meeting of Local Review Body of 6 July 2010

3. Applications for Review

   (i) TCP/11/16(34)
   Planning Application 09/02182/FLL – Alterations to house (formation of a dormer) at 34 Viewlands Terrace, Perth, PH1 1BZ – Review Papers Attached

   (a)   Papers Submitted by the Applicant [PDF: 1.87Mb] (Pages 9-18)

   (b)   Planning Decision Notice, Report of Handling and Reference Documents [PDF: 727Kb] (Pages 19-30)

   (c)   Representations [PDF: 176Kb] (Pages 31-34)

   • Letter from supporter, dated 25 January 2010
   

   (ii) TCP/11/16(35)
   Planning Application 09/02223/FLL – Erection of a dwellinghouse at Glendy Mill Cottage, Glenfarg – Review Papers Attached

   (a)   Papers Submitted by the Applicant [PDF: 4.84Mb] (Pages 35-64)

   (b)   Planning Decision Notice, Report of Handling and Reference Documents [PDF: 3.2Mb] (Pages 65-88)

   (c)   Representations [PDF: 23Kb] (Pages 89-90)

   • Letter of support from Mr and Mrs Ferguson, dated 15 January 2010
   • Letter of support from Mr G Leslie, dated 24 January 2010
   

   (iii) TCP/11/16(36)
   Planning Application 10/00116/FLL – Erection of new agricultural building at Wolfhill Farm, Guildtown, PH2 6DN – Review Papers Attached

   (a)  Papers Submitted by the Applicant [PDF: 3.81Mb] (Pages 91-106)

   (b)  Planning Decision Notice, Report of Handling and Reference Documents [PDF: 225Kb] (Pages 107-116)

   (iv) TCP/11/16(37)
   Planning Application 10/00290/FLL – First floor dormer and ground floor porch at 46 Athollbank Drive, Perth, PH1 1NF – Review Papers Attached

   (a)  Papers Submitted by the Applicant [PDF: 605Kb] (Pages 117-128)

   (b)  Planning Decision Notice, Report of Handling and Reference Documents [PDF: 82Kb] (Pages 129-136)

   (v) TCP/11/16(38)
   Planning Application 08/01210/FLL – Erection of 4 dwellinghouses at site west of Carnbo Farmhouse, Carnbo – Review Papers Attached

   (a)  Papers Submitted by the Applicant [PDF: 7.19Mb] (Pages 137-246)

   (b)  Planning Decision Notice, Report of Handling and Reference Documents [PDF: 4.74Mb] (Pages 247-284)

   (c)  Representations [PDF: 2.88Mb] (Pages 285-370)
   

   • Email of objection from Mr T Read, dated 14 July 2008
   • Letter of objection from Mrs S E Batten, dated 15 July 2008
   • Letter of objection from K W Batten, dated 15 July 2008
   • Letter of objection from Owner/Occupier, Braughty Farm, dated 17 July 2008
   • Letter of objection from Mrs E Thomson, dated 18 July 2008
   • Letter of objection from Mr I Thomson, dated 18 July 2008
   • Email and letter from Mrs J Campbell, objector, dated 19 June and 21 July 2008
   • Letter from Mr F Campbell, objector, dated 21 July 2008
   • Letter from Dr A Lavery, objector, dated 27 July 2008
   • Letter from Owner/Occupier, Rosebank, objector, received 30 July 2008
   • Letters from Mr G Nesbit, objector, dated 4 and 14 August 2008
   • Letters and email from Mr S Middleton, objector, dated 15 July 2008, 9 March 2009 and 30 October 2009
   • Letters from Ms J Middleton, objector, dated 15 July 2008 and 9 March 2009
   • Emails and letters from Mrs A Munro, objector, dated 20 June 2008, 18 July 2008, 26 January 2009 and 2 November 2009
   • Letter from Mr I Farquhar, Fossoway and District Community Council, objectors, dated 15 July 2008,
   • Letters from Scottish Natural Heritage, dated 3 September 2008, 26 August 2009 and 22 December 2009
   • Letters and email from Scottish Environment Protection Agency, dated 17 September 2009, 26 September 2009 and 11 November 2009
   • Letter of representation from Fossoway and District Community Council, dated 29 June 2010
   • Letter of representation from Dr A Lavery, dated 29 June 2010
   • Letter of representation from Mrs S E Batten, dated 1 July 2010

   (vi) TCP/11/16(39)
   Planning Application 10/00049/IPL – Erection of a dwellinghouse (in principle) at West Park, Braco, FK15 9LQ – Review Papers Attached

   (a)  Papers Submitted by the Applicant [PDF: 1.63Mb] (Pages 371-380)

   (b)  Planning Decision Notice, Report of Handling and Reference Documents [PDF: 495Kb] (Pages 381-392)

   (vii) TCP/11/16(41)
   Planning Application 10/00082/IPL – Erection of dwellinghouse (in principle) replacing former bothy at Balnabein, Grandtully, Aberfeldy, PH15 2QT – Review Papers Attached

   (a)  Papers Submitted by the Applicant [PDF: 1.08Mb] (Pages 393-400)

   (b)  Planning Decision Notice, Report of Handling and Reference Documents [PDF: 605Kb] (Pages 401-414)

   (viii) TCP/11/16(42)
   Planning Application 10/00585/FLL – Proposed extension to dwellinghouse and formation of off-street car parking at 17 Smith Lane, New Alyth, PH11 8NH – Review Papers Attached
   

   (a)  Papers Submitted by the Applicant [PDF: 5.03Mb] (Pages 415-454)

   (b)  Planning Decision Notice, Report of Handling and Reference Documents [PDF: 36Kb] (Pages 455-460)

   (c)  Representations [PDF: 438Kb] (Pages 461-466)

   • Letter of objection from Mrs I Cruickshanks, dated 16 April 2010
   • Letter of representation from Mrs I Cruickshanks, dated 28 June 2010

   (ix) TCP/11/16(43)
   10/00307/IPL – Erection of dwellinghouse at land to north west of Middle Cottage, Dalshian, Pitlochry, PH16 5TD – Review Papers Attached

   (a)  Papers Submitted by the Applicant [PDF: 12.5Mb] (Pages 467-544)

   (b)  Planning Decision Notice, Report of Handling and Reference Documents [PDF: 18Kb] (Pages 545-546)

   (c)  Representations [PDF: 23Kb] (Pages 547-548)

   • Letter from the Scottish Environment Protection Agency, dated 22 April 2010

   (x) TCP/11/16(44)
   10/00384/FLL – Erection of dwellinghouse at Plot 5, Camghouran Farm, Rannoch, Pitlochry, PH17 2QG – Review Papers Attached

   (a)  Papers Submitted by the Applicant [PDF: 3.29Mb] (Pages 549-566)

   (b)  Planning Decision Notice, Report of Handling and Reference Documents [PDF: 110Kb] (Pages 567-580)

   (c)  Representations [PDF: 419Kb] (Pages 581-594)
   

   • Letter of objection from Mr A McCrone, dated 27 March 2010
   • Letter of objection from Scottish Natural Heritage, dated 6 April 2010
   • Memo from Perth and Kinross Heritage Trust, dated 8 April 2010
   • Letter of representation from Mr A McCrone, dated 13 July 2010
   • Letter of response from Agent to Mr A McCrone’s letter, dated 2 August 2010

   (xi) TCP/11/16(45)
   10/00391/FLL – Erection of eco-dwellinghouse for an agricultural worker at Plot 1, Camghouran Farm, Rannoch, Pitlochry, PH17 2QG – Review Papers Attached

   (a)  Papers Submitted by the Applicant [PDF: 5.11Mb] (Pages 595-628)

   (b)  Planning Decision Notice, Report of Handling and Reference Documents [PDF: 101Kb] (Pages 629-640)

   (xii) TCP/11/16(46)
   10/00609/FLL – Erection of a dwellinghouse to rear of Lott’s Cottage, Waterloo – Review Papers Attached

   (a)  Papers Submitted by the Applicant [PDF: 1.7Mb] (Pages 641-650)

   (b)  Planning Decision Notice, Report of Handling and Reference Documents [PDF: 1.15Mb] (Pages 651-666)

   (c)  Representations [PDF: 86Kb] (Pages 667-670)

   • Letter of objection from Mr H Davidson, dated 6 May 2010

   (xiii) TCP/11/16(48)
   10/00735/FLL – Erection of an oak PVC conservatory to front of Windyhillock, 7 Forrest Crescent, Fowlis Wester, PH7 3NL – Review Papers Attached

   (a)  Papers Submitted by the Applicant [PDF: 2.69Mb] (Pages 671-686)

   (b)  Planning Decision Notice, Report of Handling and Reference Documents [PDF: 201Kb] (Pages 687-696)

   (xiv) TCP/11/16(49)
   10/00436/FLL – Erection of farmhouse north east of Drumcharry Steading, Keltneyburn – Review Papers Attached

   (a)  Papers Submitted by the Applicant [PDF: 15.16Mb] (Pages 697-758)

   (b)  Planning Decision Notice, Report of Handling and Reference Documents [PDF: 71Kb] (Pages 759-768)
   

   (c)  Representations [PDF: 188Kb] (Pages 769-778)

   • Email of objection from Mr M Gallacher, dated 2 April 2010
   • Email of objection from Mr T Young, dated 8 April 2010
   • Letter of objection from Glen Lyon & Loch Tay Community Council, dated 12 April 2010

   (xv) TCP/11/16(50)
   10/00674/FLL – Installation of a small scale 22kW Hannevind wind turbine to provide power to the farm business and the farm house at West Blair Farm, Glenfarg, PH2 9QW – Review Papers Attached
   

   (a)  Papers Submitted by the Applicant [PDF: 3Mb] (Pages 779-796)

   (b)  Planning Decision Notice, Report of Handling and Reference Documents [PDF: 1.15Mb] (Pages 797-824)
   

   (xvi) TCP/11/16(51)
   10/00753/FLL – Erection of a conservatory at 10 Millhill Way, Greenloaning, FK15 0LW – Review Papers Attached

   (a)  Papers Submitted by the Applicant [PDF: 2.9Mb] (Pages 825-840)

   (b)  Planning Decision Notice, Report of Handling and Reference Documents [PDF: 303Kb] (Pages 841-850)

   NOTE The following item was deferred by the Local Review Body on 11 May 2010 to enable a site visit to take place.

   (xvii) TCP/11/16(31)
   Planning Application 09/01733/IPL – Erection of dwellinghouse (in principle) at land 70 metres west of Tighnabruaich, Amulree – Review Papers Attached

   (a)  Papers Submitted by the Applicant [PDF: 1.45Mb] (Pages 850-900)

   (b)  Planning Decision Notice and Report of Handling [PDF: 18Kb] (Pages 901-902)

   (c)  Representations [PDF: 61Kb] (Pages 903-908)
   

   • Letter from Scottish Water, dated 27 October 2010
   • Memo from The Environment Service – Transport Planning, dated 7 January 2010