Local Review Body - 31 May 2011

 

Local Review Body - 31 May 2011

Last updated | 17/04/2012

A Meeting of the Local Review Body will be held in the Council Chambers, Fourth Floor, Council Building, 2 High Street, Perth on Tuesday 31 May 2011 at 10.00am.

If you have any queries please contact Yvonne Oliver on (01738) 475125 or Christina Flynn on (01738) 475450.

Those attending the meeting are requested to ensure that all mobile phones and other communication devices are switched off.

Members

Councillors M Lyle, W Lumsden and W Wilson

Agenda

1. Declarations of Interest

2. Minute of Meeting of Local Review Body of 26 April 2011

3. Applications for Review
   

   (i) TCP/11/16(94)
   Planning Application 10/02044/FLL – Change of use from former railway sidings to vehicular sales and valeting at site 70 metres west of Duntanlich, Tibbermore – Review Papers Attached
   

   (a)  Papers Submitted by the Applicant [PDF: 4.34Mb] (Pages 13-36)

   (b)  Planning Decision Notice, Report of Handling and Reference Documents [PDF: 0.94Mb] (Pages 37-50)

   (c)  Representations [PDF: 4.12Mb] (Pages 51-96)
   

   • Objection from Mr and Mrs Lambert, dated 27 December 2010
   • Objection from Ronald Gilmore, dated 27 December 2010
   • Objection from Mr and Mrs Cramond, dated 27 December 2010
   • Objection from Mr and Mrs Christie, dated 28 December 2010
   • Objection from Mrs Speedie, dated 28 December 2010
   • Objection from Methven and District Community Council, dated 29 December 2010
   • Objection from Transport Planning, dated 18 January 2011
   • Representation from Environmental Health Manager, dated 31 January 2011
   • Representation from Mr and Mrs Cramond, dated 31 March 2011
   • Response to representation from Agent, including a letter from applicant’s solicitor, dated 25 April 2011

   (ii) TCP/11/16(97)
   Planning Application 10/00078/IPL – Erection of 3 houses (in principle) at land 50 metres north west of 15 Boreland Holdings, Kinnochty – Review Papers Attached
   

   (a)  Papers Submitted by the Applicant [PDF: 15.16Mb] (Pages 97-164)

   (b)  Planning Decision Notice, Report of Handling and Reference Documents [PDF: 586Kb] (Pages 165-168)

   (c)  Representations [PDF: 251Kb] (Pages 169-172)
   

   • Representation from Transport Planning, dated 22 March 2011

   (iii) TCP/11/16(98)
   Planning Application 10/00551/FLL – Alterations and extension to form additional accommodation and storage area at Viewlands House, 25 Viewlands Road, Perth, PH1 1BL – Review Papers Attached
   

   (a)  Papers Submitted by the Applicant [PDF: 16.26Mb] (Pages 173-246)

   (b)  Planning Decision Notice, Report of Handling and Reference Documents [PDF: 257Kb] (Pages 247-252)

   (c)  Representations [PDF: 335Kb] (Pages 253-260)
   

   • Objection from George Godsman, dated 6 May 2010
   • Objection from David Howie, dated 11 May 2010
   • Objection from Mr T G Henderson, dated 20 May 2010

   (iv) TCP/11/16(99)
   Planning Application 10/02199/FLL – Alterations to form two flats at 36 North Methven Street, Perth – Review Papers Attached
   

   (a)  Papers Submitted by the Applicant [PDF: 2Mb] (Pages 261-272)

   (b)  Planning Decision Notice, Report of Handling and Reference Documents [PDF: 1.12Mb] (Pages 273-290)

   (c)  Representations [PDF: 282Kb] (Pages 291-296)
   

   • Objection from The Architectural Heritage Society of Scotland, dated 20 January 2011
   • Objection from Conservation/Design, dated 9 February 2011

   (v) TCP/11/16(100)
   Planning Application 10/01201/IPL – Residential development (in principle) at West March, Turretbank Road, Crieff, PH7 4JJ – Review Papers Attached
   

   (a)  Papers Submitted by the Applicant [PDF: 2.43Mb] (Pages 297-312)

   (b)  Planning Decision Notice, Report of Handling and Reference Documents [PDF: 6.34Mb] (Pages 313-366)

   (c)  Representations [PDF: 1.44Mb] (Pages 367-394)
   

   • Objection from The Architectural Heritage Society of Scotland, dated 8 July 2010
   • Representation from Environment and Regulatory Services, dated 27 July 2010
   • Representation from Conservation/Design, dated 30 July 2010
   • Objection from Macleod and MacCallum, dated 2 August 2010
   • Objection from Mr and Mrs Hookham, dated 6 August 2010
   • Representation from Biodiversity Officer, dated 11 August 2010
   • Objection from SEPA, dated 30 August 2010
   • Objection from SEPA, dated 20 December 2010
   • Representation from Mr and Mrs Hookham, dated 8 April 2011
   • Response to representation by Agent, dated 4 May 2011

   (vi) TCP/11/16(101)
   Planning Application 11/00194/FLL – Addition of a shower room at rear of property and a storm porch at front of the property at East Lodge, Ballechin, Pitlochry, PH19 0LW – Review Papers Attached
   

   (a)  Papers Submitted by the Applicant [PDF: 1.51Mb] (Pages 395-404)

   (b)  Planning Decision Notice, Report of Handling and Reference Documents [PDF: 316Kb] (Pages 405-414)

   (vii) TCP/11/16(102)
   Planning Application 10/01960/FLL – Erection of two new dwellings and garages at Davidsfold, North Ardbennie, Madderty, PH7 3PT – Review Papers Attached
   

   (a)  Papers Submitted by the Applicant [PDF: 8Mb] (Pages 415-472)

   (b)  Planning Decision Notice, Report of Handling and Reference Documents [PDF: 224Kb] (Pages 473-474)

   (c)  Representations [PDF: 324Kb] (Pages 475-482)

   • Objection from Peter Whitaker, dated 6 December 2010
   • Representation from Education and Children’s Services, dated 21 December 2010
   • Representation from Transport Planning, dated 13 January 2010

   (viii) TCP/11/16(103)
   Planning Application 10/01876/FLL – Conversion of existing pumping station to form a 2 bedroom dwellinghouse with new hardstanding parking space at former Pumping Station, Balnaguard – Review Papers Attached
   

   (a)  Papers Submitted by the Applicant [PDF: 2.15Mb] (Pages 483-496)

   (b)  Planning Decision Notice, Report of Handling and Reference Documents [PDF: 623Kb] (Pages 497-508)

   (c)  Representations [PDF: 0.9Mb] (Pages 509-518)
   

   • Objection from Mr and Mrs Bent, dated 7 December 2010
   • Representation from Education and Children’s Services, dated 10 December 2010
   • Objection from Mr and Mrs Croft, dated 24 December 2010
   • Representation from Transport Planning, dated 10 January 2011

   (ix) TCP/11/16(104)
   Planning Application 10/01990/FLL – Erection of holiday lodges and associated works, including extension of access track, formation of parking spaces and installation of septic tank, at land 400 metres north west of Keepers Cottage, Moneydie – Review Papers Attached
   

   (a)  Papers Submitted by the Applicant [PDF: 21.33Mb] (Pages 519-592)

   (b)  Planning Decision Notice, Report of Handling and Reference Documents [PDF: 253Kb] (Pages 593-594)

   (c)  Representations [PDF: 268Kb] (Pages 595-598)
   

   • Letter of support from British Limbless Ex-Servicemen’s Association, dated 1 November 2010
   • Letter of support from Tom Stevenson, dated 1 November 2010
   • Letter of support from Nadia Dewhurst, dated 1 November 2010
   • Letter of support from The Scottish Veterans Garden City Association (Ltd), dated 2 November 2010
   • Letter of support from Andrew Istead, dated 3 November 2010
   • Letter of support from Samina Vernon, dated 4 November 2010
   • Representation from Transport Planning, dated 17 January 2011

   (x) TCP/11/16(106)
   Planning Application 10/02068/FLL – Erection of a dwellinghouse at Cockerstone Farm, Bankfoot, PH1 4DN – Review Papers Attached
   

   (a)  Papers Submitted by the Applicant [PDF: 6.71Mb] (Pages 599-630)

   (b)  Planning Decision Notice, Report of Handling and Reference Documents [PDF: 390Kb] (Pages 631-640)

   (c)  Representations [PDF: 282Kb] (Pages 641-648)

   • Representation from Environmental Health Manager, dated 19 January 2011
   • Representation from Education and Children’s Services, dated 21 January 2011
   • Representation from Transport Planning, dated 18 February 2011

   (xi) TCP/11/16(107)
   Planning Application 10/02225/FLL – Alteration and extension to dwellinghouse at Boat House, Pier Road, Kenmore, PH15 2HJ – Review Papers Attached
   

   (a)  Papers Submitted by the Applicant [PDF: 3.4Mb] (Pages 649-676)

   (b)  Planning Decision Notice, Report of Handling and Reference Documents [PDF: 527Kb] (Pages 677-688)

   (c)  Representations [PDF: 455Kb] (Pages 689-694)

   • Representation from Community Greenspace, dated 10 February 2011
   • Representation from Conservation Officer, dated 9 March 2011

4. Deferred Applications for Review
   

   Site Visit
   

   NOTE The following applications were deferred for the purposes of an unaccompanied site visit taking place prior to consideration.

   (i) TCP/11/16(95)
   Planning Application 10/01977/FLL – Erection of 2 dwellinghouses on land to west of Old Schoolhouse, Rannoch Station, Pitlochry, PH17 2QA – Review Papers Attached
   

   (a)  Papers Submitted by the Applicant [PDF: 2.58Mb] (Pages 695-740)

   (b)  Planning Decision Notice, Report of Handling and Reference Documents [PDF: 392Kb] (Pages 741-752)

   (c)  Representations [PDF: 249Kb] (Pages 753-756)
   

   • Representation from Transport Planning, dated 13 January 2011

   (ii) TCP/11/16(96)
   Planning Application 10/01768/IPL – Erection of dwellinghouse (in principle) at land 100 metres south east of Briglands Lodge, Crook of Devon, KY13 0PS – Review Papers Attached
   

   (a)  Papers Submitted by the Applicant [PDF: 6.79Mb] (Pages 757-798)
          Supplementary Information Clarifying Page 790 [PDF: 5.54Mb] (Page 798a)
   
   (b)  Planning Decision Notice, Report of Handling and Reference Documents [PDF: 237Kb] (Pages 799-802)
   
   (c)  Representations [PDF: 250Kb] (Pages 803-808)

   • Representation from Conservation/Design, dated 4 November 2011
   • Representation from Transport Planning, 8 December 2010

   Written Submissions
   

   NOTE The following application was deferred for the purposes of further written submissions prior to consideration.

   (iii) TCP/11/16(73)
   Planning Application 10/01000/FLL – Review of Conditions 1 and 2 imposed on planning application 10/01000/FLL for change of use from agricultural building to vaulting arena (in retrospect) and extension to form ancillary storage at land 20 metres north of Hillside House, Milnathort, KY13 3NR – Review Papers Attached
   

   (a)  Papers Submitted by the Applicant [PDF: 5.44Mb] (Pages 809-832)
   
   (b)  Planning Decision Notice, Report of Handling and Reference Documents [PDF: 0.88Mb] (Pages 833-842)

   (c)  Representations [PDF: 7.55Mb] (Pages 843-860)
   

   • Objection from Montgomery Forgan Associates on behalf of Mr and Mrs Stirling, dated 12 July 2010
   • Representation from Transport Planning, dated 20 August 2010
   • Representation from Montgomery Forgan Associates on behalf of Mr and Mrs Stirling, dated 17 December 2010
   • Response to representation from Agent, dated 10 January 2011

   (d) Submission by The Environment Service – Verbal submission to be given by N Brian, Development Quality Manager
   

   (iv) TCP/11/16(75)
   Planning Application 10/01376/FLL – Alterations, extension and conversion of storage building to form dwellinghouse at site 20 metres south west of Gilfillan Court, Commercial Lane, Comrie – Review Papers Attached
   

   (a)  Papers Submitted by the Applicant [PDF: 5.33Mb] (Pages 861-892)
   

   (b)  Planning Decision Notice, Report of Handling and Reference Documents [PDF: 438Kb] (Pages 893-894)
   

   (c)  Representations [PDF: 258Kb] (Pages 895-900)
   

   • Representation from Conservation/Design, dated 6 September 2010
   • Objection from Flooding Section, dated 13 September 2010

   (d)  Written Submission by The Environment Service [PDF: 235Kb] (Pages 901-904)