Perth & Kinross Council logo

Local Review Body - 6 July 2010


Advanced Search

 

Browse

 

Local Review Body - 6 July 2010

Last updated | 01/07/2010

A Meeting of the Local Review Body will be held in the Council Chambers, Fourth Floor, Council Building, 2 High Street, Perth on Tuesday 6 July 2010 at 10.00am.

If you have any queries please contact Yvonne Oliver on (01738) 475125 or Andrew Wilson on (01738) 475172.

Those attending the meeting are requested to ensure that all mobile phones and other communication devices are switched off.

Members

Councillors B Band (Convener), M Lyle and S Miller 

Agenda

  1. Declarations of Interest

  2. Minutes

    (i) Minute of Meeting of Local Review Body of 11 May 2010

    (ii) Minute of Meeting of Local Review Body of 1 June 2010

  3. Applications for Review

    (i) TCP/11/16(23)
    Planning Application 09/01757/IPL – Erection of a dwellinghouse immediately to the north of the existing property known as 'Masirah', Mossend Green, Powmill, FK14 7NJ – Review Papers Attached

    (a)   Papers Submitted by the Applicant [PDF: 1.75Mb] (Pages 11-36)

    (b)   Planning Decision Notice and Report of Handling [PDF: 289Kb] (Pages 37-44)

    (c)   Representations [PDF: 1.05Mb] (Pages 45-52)

    • Letter from objector, dated 24 November 2009
    • Letter of representation from Mrs A Murray, 14 April 2010
    • Letter from applicant in response to objections, 31 May 2010

    (ii) TCP/11/16(25)
    10/00190/IPL – Erection of a dwellinghouse (in principle) at land 50 metres north west of Mill House, St Martins, Perth – Review Papers Attached

    (a)   Papers Submitted by the Applicant [PDF: 1.99Mb] (Pages 53-64)

    (b)   Planning Decision Notice and Report of Handling [PDF: 454Kb] (Pages 65-74)

    (c)  Representations [PDF: 586Kb] (Pages 75-98)

    • Letter of objection from Ms H Beattie and Ms V Brookes, dated 18 February 2010
    • Letter of objection from Owner/Occupier of Friar’s Cottage, St Martins, dated 20 February 2010
    • Letter of objection from Owner/Occupier of Kildonian, St Martins, dated 21 February 2010
    • Letter from Scottish Water, dated 22 February 2010
    • Letter of objection from Mr and Mrs Guest, dated 22 February 2010
    • Email of objection from Mr S Livingston, dated 23 February 2010
    • Email of objection from Ms K Antonio, dated 23 February 2010
    • Letter of objection from Mr M Payne, Burrelton and District Community Council, dated 1 March 2010
    • Letter of objection from C O’Malley, dated 2 March 2010
    • Memo of objection from Perth and Kinross Heritage Trust, dated 10 March 2010
    • Email from Perth and Kinross Heritage Trust, dated 20 April 2010

    (iii) TCP/11/16(26)
    Planning Application 10/00191/IPL – Residential development (in principle) at land 130 metres north east of Kirklands, St Martins, Perth – Review Papers Attached

    (a)  Papers Submitted by the Applicant [PDF: 1.96Mb] (Pages 99-110)

    (b)  Planning Decision Notice and Report of Handling [PDF: 273Kb] (Pages 111-120)

    (c)  Representations [PDF: 4.26Mb] (Pages 121-172)

    • Letter of objection from Ms H Beattie and Ms V Brookes, dated 18 February 2010
    • Letter of objection from Owner/Occupier of Friar’s Cottage, St Martins, dated 20 February 2010
    • Letter of objection from Owner/Occupier of Kildonian, St Martins, dated 21 February 2010
    • Letter from Scottish Water, dated 22 February 2010
    • Email of objection from Mr S Livingston, dated 23 February 2010
    • Email of objection from Ms K Antonio, dated 23 February 2010
    • Letter of objection from Ms M Danraj, dated 24 February 2010
    • Letter of objection from Mr S Urquhart, dated 25 February 2010
    • Emails from Mr S Urquhart, dated 26 February 2010
    • Letter of objection from Ms D McFarlane, dated 26 February 2010
    • Letter of objection from The Architectural Heritage Society of Scotland, dated 28 February 2010
    • Letter of objection from Mr M Payne, Burrelton and District Community Council, dated 1 March 2010
    • Email of objection from Mr C Gourlay and Ms N Gillies, dated 1 March 2010
    • Letter of objection from Owner/Occupier of St Martins Abbey, dated 2 March 2010
    • Letter of objection from C O’Malley, dated 2 March 2010
    • Letter of objection from Ms D McFarlane, dated 8 March 2010
    • Memo from Conservation Officer, dated 9 March 2010
    • Memo of representation from Perth and Kinross Heritage Trust, dated 10 March 2010
    • Email from Perth and Kinross Heritage Trust, dated 20 April 2010
    • Letter of representation from Mr S Urquhart, dated 21 April 2010

    (iv) TCP/11/16(29)
    Planning Application 09/02229/AML – Erection of a dwellinghouse, garage with upper floor accommodation and stables (Approval of Matters Specified by Conditions) at land west of North Lodge, Dunning, PH2 0QM – Review Papers Attached

    (a)  Papers Submitted by the Applicant [PDF: 1.36Mb] (Pages 173-210)

    (b)  Planning Decision Notice and Report of Handling [PDF: 298Kb] (Pages 211-220)

    (c)  Representations [PDF: 276Kb] (Pages 221-224)

    • Letter from Scottish Water, dated 26 January 2010

    (v) TCP/11/16(30)
    Planning Application 09/02230/AML – Erection of a dwellinghouse, garage with upper floor accommodation and stables (Approval of Matters Required by Conditions) at land between North Lodge and Blaeberry, Dunning, PH2 0QM – Review Papers Attached

    (a)   Papers Submitted by the Applicant [PDF: 1.5Mb] (Pages 225-266)

    (b)  Planning Decision Notice and Report of Handling [PDF: 527Kb] (Pages 267-276)

    (c)   Representations [PDF: 518Kb] (Pages 277-282)

    • Letter from Scottish Water, dated 26 January 2010
    • Memo from Education and Children’s Services, dated 3 February 2010

    (vi) TCP/11/16(31)
    Planning Application 09/01733/IPL – Erection of dwellinghouse (in principle) at land 70 metres west of Tighnabruaich, Amulree – Review Papers Attached

    (a)  Papers Submitted by the Applicant [PDF: 1.71Mb] (Pages 283-332)

    (b)  Planning Decision Notice and Report of Handling [PDF: 266Kb] (Pages 333-344)

    (c)  Representations [PDF: 275Kb] (Pages 345-350)

    • Letter from Scottish Water, dated 27 October 2010
    • Memo from The Environment Service – Transport Planning, dated 7 January 2010

    (vii) TCP/11/16(32)
    Planning Application 10/00368/FLL – Proposed small rear dormer to form one room in the roofspace at 3 Harley Terrace, Perth – Review Papers Attached

    (a)  Papers Submitted by the Applicant [PDF: 4.65Mb] (Pages 351-368)

    (b)  Planning Decision Notice and Report of Handling [PDF: 1.53Mb] (Pages 369-380)

    (viii) TCP/11/16(33)
    Planning Application 10/00120/FLL – Alterations and extension to dwellinghouse at Cabernet, Kingswell Road, Longforgan, DD2 5FJ – Review Papers Attached

    (a)  Papers Submitted by the Applicant [PDF: 9.21Mb] (Pages 381-414)

    (b)  Planning Decision Notice and Report of Handling [PDF: 279Kb] (Pages 415-422)

    NOTE The following item was deferred by the Local Review Body on 11 May 2010 to enable a site visit to take place.

    (ix) TCP/11/16(17)
    Planning Application 09/01597/IPL – Erection of 2 dwellinghouses at land 60 metres north west of 13 The Holdings, Kinfauns – Review Papers Attached

    (a)  Papers Submitted by the Applicant [PDF: 4.37Mb] (Pages 423-438)

    (b)  Planning Decision Notice, Report of Handling and Drawing No. 1 [PDF: 2.91Mb] (Pages 439-450)

    (c)  Representations [PDF: 2.19Mb] (Pages 451-472)

    • Email from Richard Anton, dated 22 September 2009
    • Email from Dr Phyllis Windsor, dated 28 September 2009
    • Email from Mr Stephen Windsor, dated 28 September 2009
    • Email from Mr Duncan Naysmith, dated 2 October 2009
    • Letter from Marie Tolland, dated 4 October 2009
    • Letter from Linda Brown, dated 4 October 2009
    • Letter from R T Brown, dated 4 October 2009
    • Email from David Rougvie, dated 7 October 2009
    • Email from Dr Eileen Williams, dated 8 October 2009
    • Letter of representation from K Tolland, dated 5 March 2010

  4. Hearing

    (i)  Procedure to be used for Hearing [PDF: 223Kb] (copy herewith) (Pages 473-474)

    (ii) TCP/11/16(8)
    Planning Application 08/02192/FLL – Extension to dwellinghouse at Cockersfauld, Muckhart Road, Dunning – Review Papers Attached

    (a)  Papers Submitted by the Applicant [PDF: 17.38Mb] (Pages 475-560)

    (b)  Planning Decision Notice and Report of Handling [PDF: 553Kb] (Pages 561-568)

    (c)  Hearing Statement submitted by the Applicant [PDF: 1.04Mb] (Pages 569-572)

    (d)  Hearing Statement submitted by the Appointed Officer [PDF: 229Kb] (Pages 573-576)